'Why is the honest PM scared of Lokpal?'

Asks Team Anna, responding to the charge that it was undermining the Parliament, Constitution

Asks Team Anna, responding to the charge that it was undermining the Parliament, Constitution

Civil society led by Anna Hazare yesterday hit back at the government over the charge that it was undermining Parliament and Constitution and asked why an "honest" man like Prime Minister Manmohan Singh was "scared" of being investigated by the Lokpal.



Two days ahead of the next meeting of the joint drafting committee on Lokpal Bill, civil society members shot off a letter to Singh alleging that the government appeared to be shrinking the scope of the anti-corruption regime and non-inclusion of the Prime Minister under the ambit of the Lokpal would be a "retrograde" step.
Raising their pitch on the issue, the activists also took on Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee for accusing the civil society of trying to undermine democracy and said his statement betrayed a "distorted understanding of democracy and arrogance of power".

U-Turn questioned
"You are one of the most honest Prime Ministers the country has had. It is ironical that your own government should seek to take the Prime Minister out of the purview of Lokpal's investigations. "We are wondering what happened post March 2011 that prompted the government to suddenly take a U-turn on this issue. Till now the Prime Minister could be investigated by the CBI. Why should an honest Prime Minister like you should be scared of being investigated by an independent Lokpal?" the activists asked in the three-page letter to Singh.

Activist Arvind Kejriwal termed the government insistence on non-inclusion of the Prime Minister under the purview of Lokpal "completely mysterious" when governments for the past 10 years were of the view that this post should come under the ombudsman.

In the letter, the activists said that in order to take the Prime Minister out of the purview of the ombudsman, the government would need to amend the Constitution and grant him immunity similar to that enjoyed by the President. They asked if the government was planning to do that and why.

'Retrograde step'
"Taking the Prime Minister out of the ambit of the Lokpal would be a retrograde step," the letter said. "We remember in the past you had yourself offered to be brought under the purview of Lokpal Bill. Then why are your own ministers opposing your inclusion in Lokpal's ambit? Is there a disconnect or communication gap within the government?" the letter said.

Interestingly, it said, three out of five ministers in the joint committee have themselves advocated inclusion of the Prime Minister in Lokpal Bill on earlier occasions. The letteru00a0 mentioned that Mukherjee, as chairman of the Standing Committee in 2001, had himself recommended that Prime Minister should be covered under Lokpal and then Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee had agreed to that.

It also said that Law Minister M Veerappa Moily, also a member of the Lokpal Bill, suggested inclusion of the Prime Minister in the legislation and Home Minister P Chidambaram had concurred with him. "Now all the three ministers have suddenly taken a U-turn and they appear to be adamant on keeping the PMO out of Lokpal's ambit. We want to know what happened that made the PMO refrain from wanting any disclosure of its conduct." said Kejriwal.

Arguing for the inclusion of the Prime Minister under the Lokpal, the letter said the post is covered under the Prevention of Corruption Act and any allegation of corruption against a Prime Minister can be investigated. No exception has been made for the Prime Minister, they said.

Yeddy takes on UPA
Lambasting the UPA government for hitting out at social crusaders like Anna Hazare and Ramdev, Karnataka Chief Minister B S Yeddyurappa yesterday challenged it to dissolve the Lok Sabha and face mid-term elections.
"The UPA government has no right to indulge in loose talk about Karnataka Lokayukta Santosh Hegde, Hazare and Ramdev when the government itself is seeped in scams like the 2G spectrum, Commmonwealth Games and Adarsh Apartments," he told a public gathering. Yeddyurappa also came down heavily on Congress leader B K Hariprasad for his remarks against Hazare
and Ramdev.