Updated On: 01 September, 2025 10:38 PM IST | Thane | mid-day online correspondent
A Thane court acquitted the man stating that the prosecution failed the ‘Panchsheel test’ for circumstantial evidence. Despite 12 witnesses and forensic findings, gaps in the chain of evidence and possible third-party involvement led the court to give the accused the benefit of doubt

The prosecution highlighted that the accused was allegedly the last person seen with the victims. Representational image
A man was acquitted in a double murder case by a Thane court which observed that the prosecution failed to meet the 'Panchsheel test' for convictions based on circumstantial evidence, news agency PTI reported.
“The test requires that each circumstance be fully established, facts be consistent only with the accused's guilt, circumstances of a conclusive nature, exclusion of all other hypotheses and a complete chain of evidence," the Thane court emphasised.
While granting bail to Kallu Raju, alias Mahabharat Yadav, Additional Sessions Judge VL Bhosale, in the order of August 19, gave the benefit of doubt to the accused, who was a waiter at a bar. According to PTI, the court said that the prosecution failed to establish a complete and conclusive chain of evidence.